As promised, here's the poll for the next(ish) installment of "Journals of the Hunter".
Thank you all very much for writing out the ideas! It was much tougher than I anticipated to narrow it down. It mostly came down to whether the monster fits within victorian England and if I can think of a way to fit it within the narrative of the story so far, however lose it is.
There were some pretty cool ideas that would require international travel, that I decided against. I am thinking travel arc is in the cards at some point.
I also rejected any idea that specifically mentioned dickgirls. That's just unfair. It would win 100%. Next one of those we'll make lady with dick themed to compensate.
Here's the options. Patrons who wrote it are in [brackets]. I edited some of these for clarity. In cases where gender of the monster was uncertain I just picked one.
A) Mind flayer/similar non copyrighted octopus headed guy. Consentacles are always hot. [Francesco Villani]
B) The Hunter discovers a starving slime girl that only feeds on sexual fluids and intestinal mucus. She won’t let her die of hunger, right? [Jon F]
C) Maybe Frankenstein's monster? The stiches and skin patches would look cool imo [Jal]
D) Maybe a grim reaper/pale horseman/apokalypse horseman? She would save the day by making a "deal" with him to spare some people ? [Tarmie]
E) Living Shadow or Drawing, like a sexy woman that lives on walls or in books that ends up covering her body like a tattoo and fingering and fondling her, or dicking her down under her clothes. [Coth]
F) Chair haunted by a (corrupted? vengeful?) dryad that molests people who sit in it. Hunter draws out it its humanoid spirit to see if she can satiate it. [Sengachi]
G) A Dullahan searching for her head; frightening to local townsfolk, but ultimately friendly and willing to reward anybody who can find it [Rosie]
H) I'd love to see something revolving around possessions, whether it be ghost or daemonic possessions of the Hunter, or someone else she needs to rescue. I could think that she has to excise a spirit from a house, and to do that, she needs to allow it to feel pleasure one last time. What better vessel for that task than her own! [Call Me ET]
I) An invisible trickster who she has to lure in by offering herself, and only parts of them are "visible" by either being covered in her fluids, or through the hand imprints/dents on her body where the trickster is grabbing/holding her [Dimi ✌🏼]
J) A Weird doppleganger who doesn't get you quite right, so it looks like a exaggerated, horned-up version of you. also wants to touch every part of your body to learn more anatomy :3c [NarizRoja]
Multiple choice enabled[if it doesn't work on mobile, try it on desktop]
This vote will end on Sunday April 21st.