Forbidden desire thumbnail poll

Hi guys! I'm currently outside of the country, so please forgive the quality of this poll's picture 🙇 I've been thumbnailing the ideas for the November goodie bag and got torn between these two ideas. Please let me know which one is your favorite composition for this month's goodie bag!

I wanted both of the ideas to include a sword. One of them has Filip grabbing the sword to the point of getting bloodied, in the second he uses it to lean back. I may tilt the tip of the sword more to the center of the picture in the final picture 🤔