Eleanor avoids suspicion in the aftermath of the chaos, while Michael fears he has failed in his first big project.
Introducing Immanuel Kant's Metaphysics of Morals, Chidi considers teaching Eleanor to be a good person.
Tahani organizes a clean up day, but anyone who volunteers will miss out on the opportunity to fly.
Chidi suggests Eleanor volunteer in order to prove that she has the capacity for selflessness. She does, but she hides the trash to go flying after all, causing a trash storm to occur. Chidi loses faith in her and refuses to help.
That night, Eleanor feels guilty and cleans the neighborhood herself. Chidi sees her and agrees to teach her to be good.
A note is slipped under Eleanor's door, warning her that she does not belong in the Good Place.
Flashbacks to Eleanor's life show that she habitually shirked the responsibility of acting as a designated driver.